Can native speakers fully pronounce tones while singing? Do they give up tones in modern songs?

Listening to lyrics in chinese is a good way to learning the language.

However, to me it sounds like the pitch is often flatened and adapts to the melody rather than the sylable tone. Is it because I am not trained enough to hear the tones? Or is it that tones become less important in songs?

Youku embed & link for Fairy Tale

(photo credit digi)

Youtube embed & link for Fairy Tale


Views: 348

Tags: culture, do chinese people use tones in songs?, music, native speakers, tones, tones in chinese music

Comment

What do you think? If you would like to comment you can join free

Join Study More Chinese


Top Member
Comment by Thomas Doherty on March 6, 2012 at 8:34pm

Australia that is !!

Not the Austealia  imaginary kingdom.


Top Member
Comment by Thomas Doherty on March 6, 2012 at 8:32pm

Many English regional accents get reduced in singing also.  Examples Beatles talking versus Beatles singing ( and most singers from just about any other English speaking country ).  Of course, on the other hand, southern USA accent seems to be exaggerated in many of their songs and people even from New England, Austealia, Canada and Ireland who want to be "country" singers will adopt it while singing.


Teacher
Comment by Shu on December 28, 2011 at 10:54am

Very good question Antonio:)

Tone is equally important in singing and in speaking. You might feel that the tones got flattened a bit due to the melody, but if you really really want to sing well a Chinese songs you have to pay attention to the details - the tones, just like if  you  want to master your Chinese speaking fluency, you do have to drill and perfect the tones too.

Thank you for sharing the song. A lot of people like that song:) You are welcome to go to my website for tips on learning Chinese and also check out the song list. I have a bunch of songs with pinyin and English translation too, including this song, yes.

http://www.chinesetolearn.com/

You are absolutely right!!! Singing is a great way to learn a language and it is a smart and joyful approach.

Happy New Year to you! Let me know if you have any question about Chinese songs :) It is one of my favorite topics.

Recommended Resource

Recommended Resource

Recommended Company

App Recommended by our Members

Upgrade your flashcard practice with WCC Chinese Flashcards (Character) with Audio on the iphone or you can read our discussion about the best Chinese apps here.

Sponsored Links

Members

Latest Activity


Top Member
Thomas Doherty replied to Thomas Doherty's discussion How to say "to ask" in Chinese - 问 "to ask" in the group Daily Chinese Sentence
"From the same source: 问问他会不会说日语。 Wèn wèn tā huì bù huì shuō rìyǔ. Pregúntale si él habla japonés. Ask him if he speaks Japanese."
6 hours ago

Top Member
Thomas Doherty replied to Thomas Doherty's discussion How to say "to ask" in Chinese - 问 "to ask" in the group Daily Chinese Sentence
"问问他他们是不是还住在东京。 Wèn wèn tā tāmen shì bùshì hái zhù zài dōngjīng. Pregúntale si todavía viven en Tokio. Ask him if they still live in Tokyo. from the Glosbe Mandarin-Spanish…"
6 hours ago

Top Member
Thomas Doherty replied to Thomas Doherty's discussion How to say "to ask" in Chinese - 问 "to ask" in the group Daily Chinese Sentence
"搜搜问问是由腾讯旗下的搜索引擎。 Sōu sōu wèn wèn shì yóu téngxùn qíxià de sōusuǒ yǐnqíng. Soso ask is Tencent's search engine."
11 hours ago

Top Member
Thomas Doherty replied to Thomas Doherty's discussion How to say "to ask" in Chinese - 问 "to ask" in the group Daily Chinese Sentence
"He asks the same question. 他问同样的问题。( or   他问同问。 ?? ) Tā wèn tóngyàng de wèntí.  (  or  Tā wèn tóng wèn.   ?? )"
11 hours ago

Top Member
Thomas Doherty replied to Thomas Doherty's discussion How to say "to ask" in Chinese - 问 "to ask" in the group Daily Chinese Sentence
"And this example 快点 去 问 问 厕所 在 哪 里。 Kuài diǎn qù wèn wèn cèsuǒ zài nǎlǐ. Hurry and go ask a while where the bathroom is. from the same site but at this link:    …"
11 hours ago

Top Member
Thomas Doherty replied to Thomas Doherty's discussion How to say "to ask" in Chinese - 问 "to ask" in the group Daily Chinese Sentence
"The use of doubled up ( verb reduplication ) of   问  ,  ie.   问 问    to mean ask a bit can be seen in this example 你 问 问 他们 厕所 在 哪里。 Nǐ wèn wèn tāmen cèsuǒ zài nǎlǐ. (You), ask them a bit…"
11 hours ago

Top Member
Thomas Doherty replied to Thomas Doherty's discussion How to say "to ask" in Chinese - 问 "to ask" in the group Daily Chinese Sentence
"Example of using a doubled up  问,   ie.   问问 : 我去问问他. Wǒ qù wèn wèn tā. I’ll go ask him. This was found in the 23 April 2014 posting on the "Learn Chinese Weekly" Blog on the…"
13 hours ago

Top Member
秦胜 replied to Thomas Doherty's discussion How to say "to ask" in Chinese - 问 "to ask" in the group Daily Chinese Sentence
"They can be used both. When quantifier is the "one", in our habits, it can be omitted."
20 hours ago

Get daily Chinese learning updates